Costello's Soup
French Onion Soup 5.50
Classic onion soup, beef broth topped with crustini, bubbly Swiss and provolone.
Costello's Italian Wedding Soup 4.50
Our family's secret recipe. Made fresh daily.
Shrimp Bisque 6.50
Hearty shrimp stock reduced with a touch of fresh cream and a hint of tomato.
Costello's Starters
Boneless Wings 7.50
Hot, Mild or BBQ sauce with bleu cheese dressing and celery.
Fried Olives 7.50
Bleu cheese stuffed green olives lightly breaded and fried with fresh marinara sauce.
Fried Mozzarella 6.95
Mozzarella sticks with a marinara dipping sauce.
Macaroni Cheese Bites 6.50
Macaroni & cheese lightly battered then flash fried, served with marinara sauce.
Bruschetta 6.95
Tomatoes, fresh basil, extra virgin olive oil served on mozzarella cheese toasted garlic French bread.
Loaded Potato Skins 6.50
Filled with crispy bacon and cheddar cheese served bubbly hot!
Deep Fried Calamari 8.95
Fresh calamari dusted with Italian bread crumb and lightly fried, served with a side of marinara sauce.
Crab Stuffed Portobella 9.95
Marinated portobella mushroom stuffed with lump crab, bleu cheese and roasted peppers.
Asian Dumplings 9.50
Steamed dumplings with a pork stuffing wrapped in a thin pasta purse, served with Asian dipping sauce.
Cheezy Garlic Bread 5.95
Fresh baked French bread topped with our own garlic herb butter and mozzarella cheese blend, served with our marinara dipping sauce.
Costello's Garden Avenue
Add Chicken for 3.00, Shrimp for 4.00, Steak or Salmon for 5.00
Soup & Salad 8.50
Choice of Costello's homemade soup with a side salad.
Avenue Caesar Salad 8.95
Fresh romaine lettuce tossed with croûtons, Parmesan cheese and house made Caesar dressing.
Island Summer Salad 9.50
Fresh pineapple, coconut, apple, orange and dried cranberries mixed in yogurt and served over mixed greens with a raspberry vinaigrette dressing.
Tuna or Chicken Salad 8.95
Your choice of our house made tuna or chicken salad over fresh mixed greens with tomatoes, onion and choice of dressing.
Crispy Chicken Salad 9.95
Lightly fried chicken over a refreshing mixed green salad with diced tomato, red onion and shredded cheddar cheese served with choice of dressing.
Fire Grilled Steak & Tomato Salad 12.95
Grilled sirloin over fresh mix greens, red onions, vine ripe tomatoes with blue cheese crumbles. Substitute shrimp no charge.
Asian Salad 8.95
Pacific rim slaw tossed with honey mustard and served over fresh mixed greens.
Teriyaki Salad 7.95
A bed of fresh mixed greens with red onion and diced tomato finished with a splash of teriyaki sauce.
Costello's Chef Salad 10.95
Egg, bacon, ham, turkey, red onion and Swiss cheese over mixed greens with tomato.
Chicken or Tuna Stuffed Tomato 8.95
Whole tomato packed full of your choice of tuna or chicken salad.
Spinach & Tomato Salad 7.95
Fresh spinach, diced tomatoes and feta cheese finished with a light vinaigrette dressing.
Greek Salad 9.95
Sliced tomatoes, cucumber, olives, red onion and feta cheese finished with olive oil.
Caprese Salad 8.95
Alternating layers of fresh sliced tomatoes and mozzarella cheese with a basil leaf between each drizzled with extra virgin olive oil.
Waldorf Salad 8.95
Chopped walnuts, grapes, julienned apples, celery and mayonnaise.
Cobb Salad 9.50
Mixed greens, tomatoes, bacon, hard boiled eggs, avocado and blue cheese crumbles finished with a dressing of your choice.
Fresh Tuna Salad & Avocado 8.50
Homemade tuna salad made with white albacore tuna and served in a half avocado.
Cold Salad Combo 10.95
One scoop of tuna salad, one scoop of chicken salad and on scoop of potato salad served with slices of tomato and hard boiled egg.
Costello's Burgers
All burgers served with House Cut Potato Chips,
Natural Cut Fries or French Fries
Classic Cheese Burger 7.95
A 1/2 lb. of fresh ground beef with lettuce, tomato and onion.
Bacon Cheddar Ranch Burger 8.95
1/2 lb. Fresh ground beef with crispy bacon, sharp cheddar cheese, lettuce, onion straws and ranch dressing.
Mozzarella Mushroom Burger 8.95
1/2 lb. Fresh burger with mozzarella, marinated portabello, shredded lettuce and BBQ sauce.
Bacon Bleu Burger 8.95
1/2 lb. Fresh ground beef with melted bleu cheese crumbles, crisp bacon and lettuce.
Turkey Burger 8.50
All white meat turkey with lettuce, tomato, onion and cranberry sauce.
Costello's Patty Melt 8.95
Sautéed onions, melted Swiss cheese and our fresh burger patty between two pieces of fresh rye bread, Thousand Island on the side.
Costello's Sandwiches
Sandwiches come with choice of one side: House Cut Potato Chips, French Fries, Natural Cut Fries, Cottage Cheese, Coleslaw, Applesauce or House Salad
Crab Cake Sandwich 9.95
Costello's signature crab cake served on a fresh kaiser roll with crisp lettuce, tomato and a side of tartar sauce.
Soup & Half Sandwich 8.50
Choice of side NOT included, A bowl of soup served with half sandwich with choice of roasted turkey, roast beef, ham, chicken or tuna salad and served on your choice of toasted bread.
Monte Cristo 8.95
Ham, turkey and Swiss on grilled French toast style bread with cranberry maple sauce.
Reuben 8.95
Your choice of turkey, roast beef or ham grilled on rye, Swiss cheese, fresh coleslaw and 1000 island dressing.
Cheese Steak 8.50
Steak topped wtih caramelized onions, pepper, cheddar and American cheese.
Open Faced Roast Beef 7.95
Served on top of fresh bread with gravy.
Buffalo Chicken Wrap 7.95
Fried chicken tenders with mild buffalo sauce, lettuce, tomato and ranch wrapped in a grilled tortilla.
Fish Taco 7.95
Blackened tilapia with coleslaw and Russian dressing on a warm tortilla.
Club Sandwich 8.95
Choice of turkey, roast beef, ham or bacon, fresh tomato, crispy bacon and lettuce stacked high with mayo.
French Dip 8.50
Shaved roast beef with melted provolone cheese and au jus on the side.
Chicken Parmesan Sandwich 7.95
Tender breaded chicken breast with cheese and our marinara sauce.
Eggplant Parmesan Sandwich 7.50
Fresh eggplant breaded and topped with our marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese, served on a kaiser bun.
Costello's Pizza
Full Sicilian 12 cuts 13.95
Half Sicilian 6 cuts 7.95
Classic 16" 13.95
Classic 10" 7.95
Toppings 1.50
Pepperoni, Fresh Garlic, Parmesan Cheese, Broccoli, Ricotta Cheese, Spinach, Meatballs, Roasted Red Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms or Extra Cheese.
Specialty Pies
Sizes: Large~Personal
Margherita 16.95~9.95
Tomato basil garlic sauce, whole tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and basil.
BBQ Chicken 16.95~9.95
Roasted chicken and red onion with a plum BBQ sauce.
Bacon Buffalo Ranch 16.95~9.95
Buffalo chicken, crispy bacon with a hint of bleu cheese.
Spinach & Garlic 15.95~8.95
Fresh spinach and garlic sautéed in extra virgin olive oil and served over Costello's famous traditional pizza.
Costello's Classics
All Classic entrées come with a choice of two sides
Ask about our House Wines!
Trim Chick 10.95
Charbroiled chicken finished with a light garlic butter sauce.
Bruschetta Chicken 15.95
Tender chicken filet topped with diced fresh tomatoes, basil, mozzarella cheese and pesto.
Chicken Tenders 12.95
Fried chicken tenders served with dipping sauce of your choice.
Mama's Meatloaf 13.95
Seasoned beef baked perfectly, mashed potatoes and gravy, vegetable & salad.
Portabella Pork Porterhouse 15.95
Pork loin chop with a portabella demi glaze.
Pork Saltimbocca 18.95
Grilled pork loin topped with prosciutto, sage, spinach and fresh mozzarella.
Eggplant Parmesan 13.95
Freshly sliced eggplant hand dipped and lightly dusted with our own Italian bread crumbs then topped with marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.
Fish & Chips 10.95
Battered and deep fried haddock served with fries, cole slaw and tartar sauce.
Chicken Marsala 16.95
Sauteed chicken breast in a rich mushroom marsala wine sauce.
Chicken Francaise 16.95
Egg battered and sauteed in a zesty lemon butter sauce.
Pasta
All pasta is served with a house salad and homemade garlic bread
Choice of Pasta: Spaghetti, Angel Hair, Penne or Linguini
Alfredo 12.95
House made Alfredo sauce over pasta with house salad. Add chicken 3.50 or shrimp 4.00
Three Cheese Ravioli 12.95
Ravioli filled with ricotta, Parmesan and Romano cheese topped wit our house red sauce with salad.
Lobster Ravioli 15.95
Ravioli stuffed with lobster and topped with our rich house made seafood sauce.
Ricotta Gnocchi 13.95
House made ricotta dumplings with fresh tomato, smoked mozzarella and a salad.
Chicken Carbonara 16.95
A house favorite! Seasoned grilled chicken, bacon, peas, parmesan cream sauce.
Shrimp Scampi 16.95
Sautéed shrimp in a lemon butter garlic sauce, fresh parsley over pasta.
Chicken Scampi 14.95
Sauteed chicken in a lemon butter garlic sauce served over pasta.
Costello's Chicken Parmesan 14.95
Hand dipped chicken, lightly dusted with Italian bread crumbs then topped with our marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese served over pasta.
Spaghetti & Meatballs 11.95
Hand formed meatballs, rich home made red sauce tossed with spaghetti.
Lasagna 13.95
Meatball lasagna with our special blend of cheese served bubbly hot.
Turkey Lasagna 13.95
Turkey meat lasagna with our special blend of cheeses.
Spinach & Crab Risotto 16.95
Maryland jumbo lump crab and spinach served in a creamy arborio sauté.
Shrimp & Broccoli Risotto 16.95
Jumbo shrimp and fresh broccoli in a creamy arborio rice sauté.
Seafood
All entrées served with choice of two sides.
Crab Cakes 16.95
Two house made Chesapeake style crab cakes baked to perfection. Suggested Wine...Riesling
Baked Haddock 15.95
Haddock with a light butter garlic sauce. Suggested Wine...Pinot Grigio
Bruschetta Haddock 16.95
Haddock topped with diced fresh tomatoes, basil, mozzarella cheese and finished with a pesto sauce. Suggested Wine...Pino Grigio
Haddock Au Gratin 16.95
Haddock topped with cheddar and mozzarella cheese, crumble bread topping and garlic butter. Suggested Wine....Chardonnay
Crab Stuffed Sole 17.95
A flavorful sole stuffed with Costello's own crabmeat stuffing and finished with a light herb butter sauce. Suggested Wine.....Pinot Grigio
Crab Encrusted Haddock 17.95
Icelandic haddock encrusted with our own crabmeat stuffing and finished with a light garlic butter sauce. Suggested Wine...Chardonnay
Grilled Salmon Filet 16.95
Wild Atlantic salmon grilled and finished with a house creole remoulade. Suggested Wine....Riesling
Beef
Costello's Flat Iron Steak 18.95
10 oz. flat iron fire grilled with au jus served with a choice of two sides. Suggested Wine...Cabernet Sauvignon
Beef Medallions 17.95
Flavorful slow marinated beef medallions served with a choice of two sides. Suggested Wine...Merlot
New York Strip 25.95
10 oz. choice fire grilled NY strip cooked to perfection and served with a choice of two sides. Suggested Wine...Cabernet Sauvignon
Filet Mignon 29.95
A hand cut 8 oz. filet char broiled to perfection and served with a choice of two sides. Suggested Wine...Merlot
Half Portion Entrées
All Half portion entrées come with a choice of One side
Crab Cake 9.95
A house made Chesapeake style crab cake baked to perfection and served with a side of cocktail sauce.
Mama's Meatloaf 7.95
Seasoned beef baked to perfection.
Chicken Tenders 6.95
Three fried chicken tenders served with dipping sauce.
Lobster Ravioli 8.95
Three raviolis stuffed with lobster and topped with our rich house made seafood sauce.
Three Cheese Ravioli 7.95
Four raviolis filled with ricotta, parmesan and romano cheeses, topped with our house sauce.
Lasagna 8.50
Meat lasagna with our special blend of cheeses served bubbly hot.
Turkey Lasagna 8.50
Turkey meat lasagna with our special blend of cheeses.
Ricotta Gnocchi 8.50
House made ricotta dumplings with fresh tomato and smoked mozzarella.
Spaghetti & Meatballs 7.95
Hand formed meatballs, rich home made red sauce tossed with spaghetti.
Shrimp Scampi 9.95
Sautéed shrimp in a lemon butter garlic sauce, fresh parsley over pasta.
Eggplant Parmesan 7.95
Freshly sliced eggplant hand dipped and lightly dusted with our own Italian bread crumbs then topped with marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.
Costello's Chicken Parmesan 7.95
Hand dipped chicken, lightly dusted with Italian bread crumbs then topped with our marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese served over pasta.
Spinach & Crab Risotto 9.95
Maryland jumbo lump crab and spinach served in a creamy arborio rice sauté.
Shrimp & Broccoli Risotto 9.95
Jumbo shrimp and fresh broccoli in a creamy arborio rice sauté.
Side Choices
House Salad
Fresh Fruit
Applesauce
Cottage Cheese
Cole Slaw
French Fries
Natural Cut Fries
Baked Potato
Potato Salad
House Cut Potato Chips
Chef's Vegetable of the Day
Side of Pasta Marinara |
